Chapter 02: The Shared Journey: Common Elements of the NDE

Imagine for a moment that you’re a detective investigating a case. You’ve interviewed hundreds of witnesses from different cities, different countries, even different continents. These witnesses don’t know each other. They come from different backgrounds—rich and poor, educated and uneducated, religious and atheist. They speak different languages and hold different beliefs about life and death. Yet when you sit down to compare their testimonies, you discover something remarkable: they’re all describing essentially the same thing. The details might vary slightly, but the core story remains strikingly consistent.

This is exactly what researchers have discovered about Near-Death Experiences (NDEs). When people from around the world come close to death and then return to life, they often report remarkably similar experiences. These shared elements form what we might call the “common journey” of the NDE—a journey that crosses all boundaries of culture, religion, age, and education.

As researcher Chris Carter observes in his comprehensive study: “The blind persons in our sample, even those blind from birth, recount experiences that clearly conform to the familiar prototype of the beatific NDE first popularized in Raymond Moody’s book, Life After Life (1975). Their narratives, in fact, tend to be indistinguishable from those of sighted persons with respect to the elements that serve to define the classic NDE pattern, such as the feelings of great peace and well being that attend the experience, the sense of separation from the physical body, the experience of traveling through a tunnel or dark space, the encounter with the light, the life review, and so forth” (Ring, Mindsight, Chapter 3).

This consistency becomes even more remarkable when we consider that even people blind from birth report visual experiences during their NDEs—seeing their own bodies from above, describing medical equipment they’ve never seen, and witnessing scenes that are later verified by medical staff. How can someone who has never had sight suddenly “see” during a near-death experience? This question challenges our basic understanding of consciousness and perception.

The Universal Pattern: Why Consistency Matters

Before we explore each element of the NDE journey, we need to understand why this consistency is so important. If NDEs were simply hallucinations caused by a dying brain, we would expect them to be as random and varied as dreams. After all, no two people have the same dreams night after night. Dreams are influenced by our daily experiences, our worries, our memories, and countless personal factors. They’re chaotic, often nonsensical, and deeply individual.

But NDEs are different. The consistency of NDEs across cultures and backgrounds is strong evidence for their reality. As Dr. Jeffrey Long notes in his extensive research: “Although no two near-death experiences are identical, it is remarkable that in thousands of reports there are consistent patterns of elements. This fact is part of what gives us confidence in their veracity” (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, Chapter 1).

This pattern holds true even in cultures with vastly different beliefs about death and the afterlife. For instance, when researchers studied NDEs in China following the 1976 Tangshan earthquake, they found that 40 percent of survivors reported NDEs with elements strikingly similar to those reported in Western countries. The researchers noted: “The typical patterning found in near-death states held up with those in China” (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Chapter on Other Cultures).

Let’s now examine each of these common elements in detail, understanding not just what people experience, but how often these elements occur and what they might mean for our understanding of life after death.

Stage 1: The Overwhelming Peace

The journey typically begins not with fear or panic, but with an extraordinary sense of peace. This might seem counterintuitive—after all, these people are dying or believe they’re dying. Shouldn’t they be terrified? Yet study after study confirms that the first and most common element of the NDE is an overwhelming feeling of peace, well-being, and freedom from pain.

Chris Carter’s analysis of multiple studies reveals: “The first stage of the NDE is usually a feeling of deep peace and wellbeing, including freedom from pain. This state is sometimes depicted as one of happiness and joy. Although there may be moments of sadness or anxiety, these tend to be transient, and the overall experience is almost always described as very enjoyable. Almost all studies report this as the most commonly found feature of the NDE, with estimates of the frequency ranging from about 56 to 100 percent of those reporting experiences while near death” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Chapter on Stages).

Think about the significance of this finding. People who are experiencing cardiac arrest, drowning, severe accidents, or other life-threatening situations suddenly find themselves enveloped in peace. The pain disappears. The fear vanishes. One experiencer described it this way: “The pain was gone and I was looking down on them working on me” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Personal Account).

This peace is not merely the absence of pain—it’s described as a positive, active experience of well-being that surpasses anything the person has felt before. The consistency of this peaceful experience across all types of medical crises suggests it’s not simply a brain reaction to trauma, but potentially a glimpse of what consciousness experiences when it begins to separate from the physical body.

From a theological perspective, this aligns with biblical descriptions of God’s presence. The Catholic understanding presented in the project materials notes: “During a positive NDE the patient’s soul has acute sensation of peace, love and harmony” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, NDE Elements). This peace echoes the biblical promise: “And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus” (Philippians 4:7).

Research data shows remarkable consistency in this element:

• The Evergreen Study found that 74.5 percent experienced overwhelming peace and serenity (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Evergreen Study Results)
• Dr. Kenneth Ring’s research reported feelings of peace in 60 percent of cases
• Some studies have found this element in up to 100 percent of NDEs

What makes this peace so remarkable is its universality. Whether the person is Christian, Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist, or atheist, whether they’re from America or India or China, this overwhelming peace appears consistently. It doesn’t depend on religious beliefs or cultural expectations. It simply happens.

Stage 2: Leaving the Body – The Out-of-Body Experience

As the sense of peace envelops them, many experiencers suddenly find themselves in a very strange position—outside their own body, typically floating above it, watching the scene below with remarkable clarity. This Out-of-Body Experience (OBE) is the second most commonly reported element of NDEs.

According to the research compiled by Carter: “The second stage of the NDE is the impression of having left one’s body. This is usually the second most commonly reported experience, with a frequency ranging from about 24 to almost 100 percent of those who have reported NDEs” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Chapter on Stages).

More specifically, the Evergreen Study found that 70.9 percent experienced an out-of-body experience (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Research Statistics). Dr. Long’s comprehensive research noted: “An out-of-body experience (OBE)” as the first of twelve common elements, describing cases where experiencers could accurately describe scenes they couldn’t have physically observed (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, Twelve Elements).

But here’s where things get truly extraordinary: these aren’t vague, dreamlike experiences. People report seeing specific details that are later verified by medical staff. They describe conversations that took place in other rooms. They identify objects placed on high shelves specifically to test OBE claims. Most remarkably, people blind from birth report being able to see for the first time during their OBEs.

Consider this account from Vicki Umipeg, who was born blind due to extreme prematurity: “I looked down at my son’s incubator and wondered, ‘Am I dead?’ But I was also thinking that it was okay if I were dead, because my son was all right. I was later given a photograph of him post-birth that looked exactly the same as what I saw, even though he was on the other side of the curtain” (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, OBE Account).

The properties of this out-of-body state are fascinating and consistent:

• Clear, enhanced perception: “Vision and hearing are usually the only two senses reported, and these are often described as enhanced to an incredible degree. Panoramic, 360° vision is sometimes reported” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, OBE Properties)
• Ability to move through solid objects: “As they came real close, I would try to turn around, to get out of their way, but they would just walk through me” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Personal Account)
• Enhanced mental clarity: “Their mental processes are clear, sharp, and rational; if anything, they report being able to think faster and more clearly than ever” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Mental State During OBE)
• Telepathic understanding: “The ability to read people’s thoughts telepathically is sometimes mentioned” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, OBE Abilities)

The out-of-body experience presents one of the strongest challenges to materialistic explanations of NDEs. If consciousness is simply produced by the brain, how can it perceive accurate information when the brain is clinically non-functional? The verified observations made during OBEs suggest that consciousness may indeed be something more than just brain activity.

Stage 3: The Journey Through Darkness – The Tunnel Experience

After separating from their body, many experiencers report moving through a dark space, often described as a tunnel, toward a brilliant light. This tunnel experience has become perhaps the most iconic image associated with NDEs, though interestingly, it’s not universal.

Research shows varying frequencies for the tunnel experience:

• The Evergreen Study found 38.2 percent experienced a tunnel or darkness (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Study Results)
• Dr. Long’s global research found tunnels reported in about 34 percent of Western NDEs
• Chinese earthquake survivors reported tunnel experiences in 16 percent of cases
• Indian studies initially found no tunnel reports, though later research found them when specifically asked about

Dr. Raymond Moody’s classic description captures the experience: “He begins to hear an uncomfortable noise, a loud ringing or buzzing, and at the same time feels himself moving very rapidly through a long dark tunnel. After this, he suddenly finds himself outside of his own physical body” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, quoting Moody).

But why the variation? Dr. Bruce Greyson’s research provides insight: “I was a bit surprised to discover, after I went through the rigorous procedure to create the scale, that it turned out not to include some things that are common in NDEs, like going through a tunnel. People do report going through a tunnel in NDEs, but they also report going through a tunnel in many other kinds of experience… The fact remains that people experience tunnels along with the other NDE features about as often as they experience tunnels without those other features” (Greyson, After, NDE Scale Development).

The variation in tunnel reports across cultures has led to fascinating discussions about how cultural symbols might shape the description of the experience. As researcher Allan Kellehear notes: “In Western reports of a tunnel experience when near death, this development materializes in the common shapes and symbols mentally associated with modernity and technology” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Cultural Interpretations).

In non-Western cultures, the same transitional experience might be described differently:

• Native Americans might describe passing through a cave
• Some Asian experiencers report “emerging through the throat of a lotus flower”
• Others simply describe “moving through darkness” without the tunnel imagery

Whether described as a tunnel, a path through darkness, or a transitional space, this element seems to represent the journey between the physical world and the spiritual realm. The consistency lies not in the specific imagery but in the experience of transition—moving from one state of being to another, from darkness toward light.

Stage 4: The Encounter with Light – Meeting the Divine

At the end of the tunnel or period of darkness, experiencers often encounter something that transforms their entire understanding of reality: a light unlike any earthly light. This is not merely bright illumination—it’s described as a living, conscious, loving presence that many identify as divine.

The statistics reveal how common this element is:

• The Evergreen Study: 56.4 percent saw a light (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Research Data)
• Some studies report this element in up to 80 percent of deeper NDEs
• Dr. Pim van Lommel’s cardiac arrest study: 23 percent reported communicating with “the light” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Statistics)

But what makes this light so special? It’s not just its brightness—though experiencers consistently report it’s brilliantly bright yet doesn’t hurt their eyes. The most striking aspect is that this light radiates unconditional love, complete understanding, and absolute acceptance.

Dr. Moody’s composite description states: “Others come to meet and help him. He glimpses the spirits of relatives and friends who have already died, and a loving, warm spirit of a kind he never encountered before—a being of light—appears before him. This being asks him a question, nonverbally, to make him evaluate his life and helps him by showing him a panoramic, instantaneous playback of the major events of his life” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Moody’s Description).

The theological implications are profound. The Catholic perspective notes: “The light does not remain simply light, but becomes one or more persons. The persons who are formed are members of Christ, (the body of Christ), and they may be any member of the person of Christ: Jesus, deceased family, Moses, a saint, guardian angel, Buddha” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Light Beings).

This aligns remarkably with biblical descriptions:

• “God is light; in him there is no darkness at all” (1 John 1:5)
• “The city does not need the sun or the moon to shine on it, for the glory of God gives it light, and the Lamb is its lamp” (Revelation 21:23)

What’s particularly striking is how this encounter with the light affects experiencers regardless of their religious background. Dr. Steve Miller’s research found: “Even those who experienced only a brief NDE were typically motivated to change their lives – specifically to love, serve, and help people” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, The Priority of Love).

The being of light often communicates without words, through what experiencers describe as telepathy or direct thought transfer. The communication is instantaneous, complete, and impossible to misunderstand. Many report that in the presence of this light, they suddenly understand profound truths about existence, purpose, and love that they struggle to express in human language afterward.

Stage 5: The Reunion – Meeting Deceased Loved Ones

One of the most emotionally powerful elements of many NDEs is the reunion with deceased relatives and friends. These aren’t vague, shadowy figures from memory—experiencers describe vivid, “more real than real” encounters with specific individuals who have died, often including relatives they didn’t know had passed away.

Dr. Long’s research identifies this as the sixth common element: “Encountering deceased relatives/friends or mystical beings” (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, Twelve Elements). The frequency varies by study, but it’s consistently reported across cultures:

• Western studies: 30-40 percent report meeting deceased loved ones
• Dr. van Lommel’s study: 20 percent reported meeting deceased relatives
• Cross-cultural studies show similar percentages globally

What makes these encounters particularly evidential are cases where the experiencer meets someone they didn’t know was dead. Chris Carter reports: “The patient died within ten minutes. It was three weeks later that my husband decided I was well enough to be told that my dear friend in that other town had died in an accident on the day my daughter was born” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Verified Death Case).

These “Peak in Darien” experiences—named after a 19th-century book describing such cases—provide some of the strongest evidence that NDEs are more than hallucinations. How could a dying brain hallucinate meeting someone it doesn’t know is dead?

The nature of these reunions is consistently described as joyful, loving, and purposeful. The deceased relatives often serve as guides or greeters, helping the experiencer adjust to their new state. Sometimes they deliver messages, provide comfort, or explain why the experiencer must return to life.

From a theological perspective, this aligns with the Christian concept of the “communion of saints” (Hebrews 12:1). The Catholic understanding affirms: “Meeting loved ones resonates with the ‘communion of saints'” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Biblical Alignments).

Stage 6: The Life Review – Seeing Through the Eyes of Love

Perhaps no element of the NDE is more transformative than the life review—a panoramic, often instantaneous replay of one’s entire life, but with a profound twist: the experiencer doesn’t just watch their life like a movie; they experience it from multiple perspectives, including the perspectives of those they affected.

The frequency of life reviews varies significantly:

• Dr. Kenneth Ring reported life reviews in 25 percent of NDEs
• Dr. Michael Sabom found them in only 3 percent of his cases
• The Evergreen Study found only 9 percent had a panoramic life review
• Overall, Western studies average about 13 percent
• Chinese earthquake survivors reported life reviews in much higher percentages

Dr. Moody’s description captures the essence: “At some point he finds himself approaching some sort of barrier or border, apparently representing the limit between earthly life and the next life. At some stage of the NDE, often after encountering the being of light, the individual may experience a life review. This review is in the form of unusually vivid, almost instantaneous images of either the person’s whole life or a few selected highlights” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Life Review Description).

But this is no ordinary remembering. Experiencers describe:

• Experiencing events from others’ perspectives: “Sometimes individuals report re-experiencing a past event while feeling great empathy with others who were involved, sometimes even experiencing the event from the perspective of those they have hurt” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Life Review Features)
• Understanding the ripple effects of their actions: Every action, word, and even thought is seen in the context of how it affected others, sometimes across generations
• Feeling both the pain they caused and the joy they brought: This isn’t judgment from outside but a deep, empathetic understanding from within
• Instantaneous yet detailed: “In many cases, the images may appear in an orderly, chronological sequence; in others, they seem to appear all at once” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Life Review Characteristics)

One English gentleman described his life review: “My life passed before me in a momentary flash but it was entire, even my thoughts were included. Some of the contents caused me to be ashamed but there were one or two I had forgotten about of which I felt quite pleased. All in all, I knew that I could have lived a much better life, but it could have been a lot worse. Be that as it may, I knew that it was all over now and there was no going back” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Personal Account).

The life review often becomes the catalyst for profound life changes after the NDE, as experiencers realize that what matters most is not success, achievement, or acquisition, but love, kindness, and service to others.

The theological parallel is striking. The life review mirrors the biblical concept of judgment, but with a crucial difference—it’s not punitive but educational. As Paul writes: “For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, so that each of us may receive what is due us for the things done while in the body, whether good or bad” (2 Corinthians 5:10). Yet in the NDE life review, this “judgment” is experienced as perfect understanding and love rather than condemnation.

Allan Kellehear’s research provides fascinating cultural context: “Life review in people of this cultural orientation is part of the general social and psychological process of identity formation, a task of ongoing personal importance in cultures with little or no regard for tribe or totem” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Cultural Analysis). This may explain why life reviews are less common in collectivist cultures that emphasize group identity over individual conscience.

Stage 7: The Heavenly Realm – Entering Paradise

In the deepest NDEs, experiencers report entering a realm of indescribable beauty—landscapes of extraordinary colors, celestial cities, gardens of impossible perfection, and music that touches the soul directly. This element, while less common than the initial stages, provides some of the most detailed and convincing accounts of an afterlife.

Research frequencies show:

• About 30-35 percent of NDEs include entry into otherworldly realms
• The Evergreen Study found 34.5 percent experienced entering an “inner setting”
• Deeper, longer clinical deaths correlate with more frequent heavenly realm experiences

Chris Carter’s compilation of research describes: “In the deepest stage of the NDE, the experiencer enters the light. Many say it is like encountering a world of preternatural beauty, describing meadows or gardens with astounding colors; magnificent cities may be seen in the distance; wonderful, ethereal music may be heard. The overwhelming loveliness, color, and soft, diffuse lighting clearly set this world apart from any earthly scene” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Entering the Light).

Common features of the heavenly realm include:

• Colors beyond earthly spectrum: Experiencers struggle to describe colors that don’t exist on Earth
• Music of extraordinary beauty: Often described as choral or orchestral but beyond human composition
• Landscapes of perfection: Gardens, meadows, mountains, and cities of incredible beauty
• Beings of light: Angels, guides, and other luminous entities
• Structures of significance: Libraries, temples, healing centers, and places of learning
• Atmosphere of love: The entire realm radiates love, acceptance, and joy

The theological parallels are unmistakable. These descriptions echo biblical visions of heaven:

• “He showed me the Holy City, Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God. It shone with the glory of God, and its brilliance was like that of a very precious jewel” (Revelation 21:10-11)
• “No longer will there be any curse. The throne of God and of the Lamb will be in the city, and his servants will serve him” (Revelation 22:3)

What’s particularly interesting is that even those without religious beliefs or with different religious expectations report remarkably similar heavenly realms. This suggests that the experience transcends individual religious conditioning and may represent an objective spiritual reality.

Stage 8: The Boundary and the Choice – The Point of No Return

Many experiencers report reaching a boundary or limit—a point beyond which they sense they cannot pass and still return to earthly life. This boundary takes various forms across different accounts but represents the same threshold between life and death.

Common boundary representations include:

• A fence, wall, or hedge
• A river, stream, or body of water
• A door, gate, or portal
• A line in the sand or invisible barrier
• A bridge or pathway
• Simply a knowing that going further means not returning

Dr. Long identifies this as element eleven: “Encountering a boundary or barrier” (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, Common Elements). The frequency varies but appears in approximately 20-30 percent of NDEs.

At this boundary, a crucial decision is made—or more accurately, communicated. The experiencer is either told they must return, given a choice about returning, or simply knows they cannot cross yet. The reasons given for return are remarkably consistent:

• “It’s not your time”—the most common message
• Unfinished business: Tasks yet to complete on Earth
• Family needs: Often related to raising children or caring for others
• A specific mission or purpose: Something important they must accomplish
• To share their experience: To tell others what they’ve learned

The Catholic perspective notes: “The Boundary: reaching a point of no return before being sent back” as a common element that aligns with scriptural concepts (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Common Elements).

Many experiencers report not wanting to return. The peace, love, and beauty of the other side make earthly life seem painful and limited by comparison. Yet they’re either gently commanded to return or come to understand why they must go back.

The Return – Coming Back to Life

The return to the physical body is often the most difficult part of the NDE. After experiencing unlimited consciousness, perfect peace, and unconditional love, returning to a pain-filled, limited physical body can be jarring or even traumatic.

Dr. Long notes this as the twelfth element: “A voluntary or involuntary return to the body” (Long and Perry, God and the Afterlife, Final Element). The return happens in various ways:

• Instantaneous: “The subject then usually finds himself back in the body instantaneously” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Return Experience)
• Through the tunnel: Traveling back the way they came
• With a jolt: “Occasionally individuals will experience a jolting sensation upon return” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Return Characteristics)
• Gradual awareness: Slowly becoming aware of physical sensations
• Sudden pain: “I hit the hospital bed with an electrifying jerk and the pain was back” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Personal Account)

Many experiencers report a period of disappointment, depression, or frustration after returning. They’ve glimpsed something extraordinary and must now return to ordinary life. Yet this difficult transition is often followed by profound positive changes.

The Transformation – Life After the NDE

Perhaps the most compelling evidence for the reality of NDEs is not what happens during the experience but what happens afterward. The vast majority of experiencers report that their NDE was the single most significant event of their lives, leading to profound and lasting changes in values, beliefs, and behavior.

Chris Carter’s research summary states: “Most of the individuals who have had an NDE feel that it has been the single most significant event of their lives. The nature of the NDE may be controversial, but there is little disagreement that the experience usually has profound, life-changing aftereffects” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, After Effects).

Common transformative changes include:

• Loss of fear of death: Not just reduced fear but often complete absence of death anxiety
• Increased spirituality: But often decreased interest in organized religion
• Enhanced appreciation for life: Every moment becomes precious
• Increased compassion and empathy: A deep understanding of others’ suffering
• Reduced materialism: Material success loses its appeal
• Thirst for knowledge: Especially spiritual and philosophical understanding
• Sense of mission or purpose: Knowing they returned for a reason
• Psychic or intuitive abilities: Many report enhanced intuition or sensitivity
• Difficulty with relationships: Especially if others don’t understand their transformation

Dr. Kenneth Ring’s research found: “A statistical analysis showed that many personality and value changes were similar for both experiencers and nonexperiencers. There were more parallels than contrasts, but where there were differences, they tended to favor the experiencers. The main differences were that a higher percentage of experiencers tended to report an increased appreciation of life, a renewed sense of purpose, being a stronger person, being more patient and understanding, and an increased empathy for others” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Transformation Research).

These transformations persist for years, even decades, after the NDE. This lasting change argues strongly against dismissing NDEs as mere hallucinations or oxygen-deprived fantasies.

Dr. Penny Sartori’s five-year clinical study found: “Years after their experiences, a ‘huge majority’ reported that ‘religious/spiritual life was of increased importance to them'” (Is Christianity Compatible With Deathbed and Near-Death Experiences?, Research Findings).

Cross-Cultural Consistency: The Universal Journey

One of the most compelling aspects of NDE research is the consistency of experiences across vastly different cultures. If NDEs were purely products of cultural conditioning or religious expectation, we would expect radical differences between, say, a Hindu from India and a Christian from America, or between an atheist from China and a Muslim from Saudi Arabia.

Yet the research shows remarkable consistency. Dr. Jeffrey Long’s analysis of over 3,000 NDEs from dozens of countries found: “All near-death experience elements appearing in Western NDEs are present in non-Western NDEs. There are many non-Western NDEs with narratives that are strikingly similar to the narratives of typical Western NDEs. At a minimum, it may be concluded that non-Western NDEs are much more similar to Western NDEs than dissimilar” (Hagan, The Science of Near-Death Experiences, Cross-Cultural Studies).

When examining non-Western NDEs, researcher Steve Miller found: “As in western NDEs, some experienced only a few of the elements, while others reported a much deeper experience. But I found all the common western elements in the nonwestern experience: leaving the body, heightened senses, positive emotions, stating that it was definitely real, a tunnel experience, seeing a light, meeting deceased relatives, talking to celestial beings, altered time and space, life review, a beautiful heavenly realm, special knowledge, coming to a barrier, returning to the body, changed lives, and the overwhelming priority of love” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, Cross-Cultural Findings).

Research from specific cultures confirms this pattern:

China (Tangshan Earthquake Study, 1976):

• 40 percent of survivors reported NDEs
• Similar elements to Western NDEs despite different cultural background
• Life reviews were actually MORE common than in Western studies
• “The typical patterning found in near-death states held up with those in China” (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Chinese Studies)

India:

• Core elements remain consistent
• Meeting deceased beings and otherworldly figures common
• Some cultural variations in interpretation (Yamaraj instead of angels)
• Later studies found tunnel experiences when specifically asked
• “The experiences of the Indian patients were similar to those of the American patients” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, India Studies)

Muslim Countries:

• Recent studies show similar NDE patterns
• Being of light often identified with religious figures from Islam
• Core transformative message remains consistent
• Focus on love, compassion, and service after the experience

What varies between cultures is often the interpretation or description, not the core experience. As Dr. Hagan notes in cross-cultural research: “The manner in which we describe an unusual experience is obviously determined in large part by the experiences typical of our culture. If descriptions of the NDE are in largely metaphorical terms, we should not be surprised, especially given the fact that the NDE is often described as ineffable, that is, beyond words” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Cultural Interpretations).

Children’s NDEs: Pure Experience Without Cultural Overlay

Some of the most compelling evidence for the reality of NDEs comes from the experiences of very young children. Children who have NDEs before they’ve been extensively exposed to religious teachings or cultural concepts about death report experiences remarkably similar to those of adults.

Dr. Cherie Sutherland’s thirty-year review of children’s NDEs concluded: “It has often been supposed that the NDEs of very young children will have a content limited to their vocabulary. However, it is now clear that the age of children at the time of their NDE does not in any way determine its complexity. Even pre-linguistic children have later reported quite complex experiences…. Age does not seem in any way to affect the content of the NDE” (Hagan, The Science of Near-Death Experiences, Children’s NDEs).

This finding is extraordinary. If NDEs were products of cultural conditioning or religious training, how could pre-verbal children have complex experiences identical to those of adults? Young children report:

• Out-of-body experiences with verified observations
• Encounters with deceased relatives, including ones they’ve never met
• Experiences with beings of light
• Journeys through tunnels or darkness
• Visits to beautiful otherworldly realms
• Being told it’s “not time” to stay

These children often struggle to express their experiences with their limited vocabulary, but the core elements remain consistent with adult experiences. This provides powerful evidence that NDEs are not constructed from pre-existing beliefs or expectations but represent genuine experiences of consciousness.

The Priority of Love: The Universal Message

If there’s one message that emerges consistently from NDEs across all cultures, religions, and backgrounds, it’s the supreme importance of love. Not romantic love or even familial love specifically, but a universal, unconditional love that encompasses all beings.

Dr. Steve Miller observes: “I was amazed that even those who experienced only a brief NDE were typically motivated to change their lives – specifically to love, serve, and help people” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, The Priority of Love).

This transformation toward love is particularly striking because it’s so consistent regardless of the person’s previous values or priorities. Miller asks the crucial question: “Love is not consistently pushed as THE main thing in life in every family and every culture. So if NDEs were merely hallucinations of dying brains, informed by our own very diverse values, why doesn’t the hedonist come back saying, ‘I’ve got only one brief life to live. I need to start my bucket list of exciting things to do before I die!’ Why doesn’t the high achiever come back saying, ‘I learned that I should take school more seriously, bringing my B’s up to A’s’?” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, Love Consistency).

The answer seems clear: NDEs are not projections of individual values or desires but encounters with a deeper reality where love is the fundamental force.

This emphasis on love aligns perfectly with Christian teaching. As Paul writes in 1 Corinthians 13:13: “And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.” The being of light encountered in so many NDEs consistently emphasizes that what matters in life is not achievement, wealth, or even religious observance, but how we love and serve others.

Distressing NDEs: The Other Side of the Coin

While most NDEs are positive, researchers have documented a significant minority of distressing or hellish experiences. These challenging NDEs actually strengthen the case for the reality of the phenomenon—if NDEs were merely wish-fulfillment or comforting hallucinations, why would anyone have a terrifying experience?

The Evergreen Study found that 20 percent of experiencers had “hellish” experiences, defined as “one that contains extreme fear, panic, or anger” (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Negative NDEs). Other studies report distressing NDEs in 10-25 percent of cases.

Types of distressing NDEs include:

• Inverse NDEs: Where typical elements are experienced as frightening
• Hellish visions: Encounters with demonic beings or realms of torment
• The Void: Experiences of absolute emptiness, isolation, and meaninglessness
• Judgment experiences: Overwhelming guilt or sense of condemnation

The Catholic understanding acknowledges: “During a distressing NDE the soul senses disorder and evil, to some degree great or small” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Distressing NDEs). These experiences often serve as powerful wake-up calls, leading to dramatic life changes and spiritual transformation.

Interestingly, many distressing NDEs transform into positive ones when the experiencer calls out for help, prays, or surrenders to the experience. This pattern suggests that the distressing elements may serve a purpose—confronting individuals with the consequences of their choices or the state of their souls.

Veridical Perception: The Evidence That Demands Explanation

Perhaps the most challenging aspect of NDEs for materialist explanations is veridical perception—cases where experiencers accurately report information they couldn’t possibly have known through normal means.

These cases include:

• Accurate descriptions of medical procedures: Patients describing specific tools, techniques, and conversations while clinically unconscious
• Observations of events in distant locations: Seeing and later reporting what family members were doing in waiting rooms or at home
• Hidden target identification: Reading numbers or identifying objects placed where only someone floating above their body could see them
• Meeting deceased individuals not known to be dead: The “Peak in Darien” cases mentioned earlier
• Blind individuals seeing: Perhaps the most remarkable—people blind from birth accurately describing visual scenes

The Dutch cardiologist Dr. Pim van Lommel’s study included this remarkable case: “A patient accurately describing the location of their dentures, which were removed while they were comatose” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Verified Cases). The patient had been clinically dead with no measurable brain activity when the dentures were removed, yet later described exactly where they were placed.

Dr. Kenneth Ring’s study of NDEs in blind individuals found: “The blind persons in our sample, even those blind from birth, recount experiences that clearly conform to the familiar prototype of the beatific NDE… Their narratives, in fact, tend to be indistinguishable from those of sighted persons” (Ring, Mindsight, Research Summary).

These veridical perceptions pose an insurmountable challenge to purely physiological explanations. How can a non-functioning brain gather and process accurate information? How can someone born blind suddenly see? The most parsimonious explanation is that consciousness can indeed function independently of the physical brain.

The Implications: What NDEs Tell Us About Human Nature

The consistent elements of NDEs across cultures, ages, and beliefs point to profound truths about human nature and destiny. These experiences suggest that:

1. Consciousness survives bodily death: The clarity of thought, enhanced perception, and verified observations during clinical death strongly suggest consciousness is more than brain activity.
2. We are spiritual beings: The out-of-body experience and the ability to perceive without physical senses indicate we have a spiritual component—what religious traditions call the soul.
3. Love is fundamental to existence: The universal emphasis on love as the most important aspect of life suggests it’s not just a human emotion but a cosmic principle.
4. Life has meaning and purpose: The life review and the reasons given for return indicate that each life has significance and purpose.
5. Our actions have consequences: The life review’s emphasis on how we affect others shows that moral choices matter deeply.
6. Death is a transition, not an end: The consistent reports of continued consciousness and existence in another realm suggest death is a doorway, not a wall.
7. There is a divine presence: The being of light encountered by so many, radiating unconditional love and wisdom, points to the reality of God.

These implications align remarkably with biblical teaching about human nature. The Catholic perspective notes that NDEs support the doctrine of substance dualism—the belief that humans consist of both physical body and immaterial soul: “We are a union of a physical body and an immaterial soul. The soul is the true ‘self'” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Dualism).

The apostle Paul’s writings resonate with NDE reports: “Therefore we do not lose heart. Though outwardly we are wasting away, yet inwardly we are being renewed day by day… So we fix our eyes not on what is seen, but on what is unseen, since what is seen is temporary, but what is unseen is eternal” (2 Corinthians 4:16, 18).

Addressing the Skeptics: Why Alternative Explanations Fall Short

Skeptics have proposed various physiological and psychological explanations for NDEs, but none adequately account for all the evidence. Let’s examine why these alternatives fail:

1. Oxygen Deprivation (Hypoxia):

Critics suggest NDEs result from lack of oxygen to the brain. However, as Chris Carter notes: “Hypoxia causes confusion, not lucid, structured experiences” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, Objections). NDEs involve enhanced mental clarity, not the confusion typical of oxygen deprivation. Furthermore, many NDEs occur without any oxygen deprivation at all.

2. Dying Brain Hypothesis:

The theory that NDEs are the brain’s last gasps of activity fails to explain:

• How can a dying brain produce the most lucid experience of a person’s life?
• Why do these experiences have consistent structure across all people?
• How do people have verified perceptions when their brains show no activity?
• Why do similar experiences occur in non-life-threatening situations?

3. Hallucinations from Drugs or Chemicals:

Dr. Long’s research addressed this: “NDEs occur in the absence of any drugs that could cause hallucinations. Moreover, drug-induced hallucinations are typically confused, fragmented, and quickly forgotten, while NDEs are lucid, coherent, and remembered vividly for decades” (God and the Afterlife, Drug Hypothesis).

The endorphin hypothesis suggests natural painkillers cause NDEs, but this “fails to explain the consistency and, most importantly, cannot account for veridical OBEs” (Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven, Chemical Explanations).

4. Psychological Explanations:

The wishful thinking hypothesis suggests NDEs are psychological defenses against the fear of death. But this fails to explain:

• Why do people have distressing NDEs?
• Why do children too young to understand death have NDEs?
• Why do the experiences contradict people’s religious expectations?
• Why atheists who don’t believe in an afterlife have classic NDEs?

As Carter concludes: “This hypothesis is simply not supported by the empirical data. While we have seen that there are some cross-cultural variations in the content of NDEs, individuals sometimes report experiences that conflict with their religious and personal expectations of death” (Carter, Science and the Near-Death Experience, Psychological Explanations).

5. Temporal Lobe Seizures:

Some researchers suggest NDEs result from temporal lobe activity. However, temporal lobe seizures produce fragmented, confused experiences with significant memory problems afterward. NDEs are coherent, meaningful, and remembered with exceptional clarity even decades later.

Furthermore, induced temporal lobe stimulation has never produced anything resembling the full NDE experience, especially not verified out-of-body perceptions or encounters with deceased individuals unknown to be dead.

The Scientific Revolution: NDEs and the Study of Consciousness

The study of NDEs is contributing to a revolution in our understanding of consciousness. For over a century, materialist science has assumed that consciousness is merely a byproduct of brain activity—when the brain dies, consciousness ceases. NDEs challenge this fundamental assumption.

Dr. Pim van Lommel, after his groundbreaking study of cardiac arrest patients, concluded: “The paradoxical occurrence of heightened, lucid awareness and logical thought processes during a period of impaired cerebral perfusion raises particularly perplexing questions for our current understanding of consciousness and its relation to brain function” (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Scientific Challenges).

This research is leading some scientists to consider that consciousness might be fundamental to the universe rather than produced by the brain. The brain might function more like a receiver or transmitter of consciousness rather than its generator. This would explain how consciousness can continue and even be enhanced when brain function ceases.

The implications extend beyond NDEs to questions about:

• The nature of death and dying
• The relationship between mind and brain
• The possibility of consciousness existing at quantum levels
• The interconnectedness of all consciousness
• The fundamental nature of reality itself

Theological Convergence: Where NDEs Meet Scripture

While NDEs should not be taken as new revelation or used to establish doctrine, the remarkable convergence between NDE reports and biblical teaching is striking. The Catholic analysis notes several points of alignment:

Points of Convergence with Scripture:

• “The Being of Light aligns with ‘God is light’ (1 John 1:5) and the glory of the Lamb (Revelation 21:23)” (A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience, Biblical Alignments)
• “The Life Review parallels the Judgment Seat of Christ (2 Corinthians 5:10)”
• “Heavenly realms echo descriptions of the New Jerusalem (Revelation 21)”
• “Meeting loved ones resonates with the ‘communion of saints’ (Hebrews 12:1)”

The apostle Paul’s own experience, likely an NDE following his stoning at Lystra, provides a biblical precedent: “I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago was caught up to the third heaven. Whether it was in the body or out of the body I do not know—God knows. And I know that this man—whether in the body or apart from the body I do not know, but God knows—was caught up to paradise and heard inexpressible things, things that no one is permitted to tell” (2 Corinthians 12:2-4).

Paul’s account contains classic NDE elements:

• Out-of-body uncertainty (“whether in the body or out of the body”)
• Journey to another realm (“caught up to the third heaven”)
• Ineffability (“heard inexpressible things”)
• Transformation (Paul’s ministry was profoundly affected)

While maintaining Scripture as the final authority, we can see NDEs as potential glimpses of the reality Scripture describes—not new revelation but contemporary confirmation of ancient truths.

The Challenge of Integration: Living After an NDE

For those who have NDEs, integrating the experience into daily life can be challenging. They’ve glimpsed eternity and must now navigate the temporal. They’ve experienced unconditional love and must return to a world of conditions and judgments. They’ve known unity and must live in separation.

Common integration challenges include:

• Difficulty expressing the experience: Language seems inadequate to convey what they’ve experienced
• Relationship changes: Values and priorities shift, sometimes causing friction with family and friends
• Career reassessment: Many change careers to more service-oriented work
• Spiritual seeking: Increased hunger for spiritual understanding and growth
• Sensitivity increases: Many report increased empathy and psychic sensitivity
• Processing the return: Why were they sent back? What is their purpose?

The church and society at large are still learning how to support and integrate NDErs. Too often, their experiences are dismissed or pathologized rather than recognized as potentially transformative spiritual encounters. As one researcher notes: “Unfortunately, with these Biblical teachings having become ingrained in formal religious beliefs, near-death experiencers get more than they bargained for when they begin to share their stories” (Atwater, The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences, Religious Reception).

The Bigger Picture: NDEs and Human Destiny

When we step back and look at the consistent elements of NDEs—the peace, the light, the love, the life review, the purposeful return—a picture emerges of human life as deeply meaningful, morally significant, and spiritually destined.

NDEs suggest that:

• Every human life has inherent value and purpose
• Our choices matter not just for ourselves but for how they ripple out to affect others
• Love is not just a nice ideal but the fundamental law of existence
• Death is not the end but a transition to greater life
• We are accountable for our lives but held in unconditional love
• There is hope beyond our greatest failures and fears

The consistent message from thousands of NDEs across all cultures is clear: We are loved beyond measure, our lives have profound meaning, and death is not the end but a doorway to greater existence.

This message resonates deeply with the Christian gospel. Jesus said, “I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full” (John 10:10). The NDEs seem to confirm that this “full life” extends beyond physical death into an existence of unimaginable love, beauty, and purpose.

Conclusion: The Significance of the Shared Journey

The common elements of NDEs—this shared journey that transcends culture, religion, age, and expectation—present us with compelling evidence that death is not the end of consciousness. The consistency of these experiences across thousands of cases worldwide suggests they are not random hallucinations or cultural constructions but glimpses of an objective spiritual reality.

From the initial overwhelming peace to the encounter with divine light, from the life review that reveals the importance of love to the reluctant return with a mission, each element of the NDE journey points toward profound truths about human nature and destiny. We are more than our physical bodies. Consciousness appears to exist independent of the brain. Love is fundamental to existence. Life has meaning and purpose that extends beyond death.

The research of dedicated scientists and medical professionals over the past fifty years has moved NDEs from the realm of anomaly to acknowledged phenomenon. Studies in prestigious medical journals, research in cardiac units worldwide, and the testimony of thousands of credible witnesses have established that something remarkable happens when people approach death.

For the Christian, these experiences need not challenge faith but can deepen it. While Scripture remains our ultimate authority, NDEs can serve as contemporary testimonies to the reality of the spiritual dimension described in the Bible. They remind us that we are “strangers and pilgrims” in this world (1 Peter 2:11), that our true citizenship is in heaven (Philippians 3:20), and that the love of God is more overwhelming than we can imagine.

Yet NDEs also transcend religious boundaries, suggesting that God’s love and the reality of consciousness beyond death are universal truths accessible to all humanity. The Muslim, the Hindu, the Buddhist, the atheist—all report similar encounters with transcendent love and beauty. This doesn’t diminish Christian truth but perhaps reveals, as Paul wrote, that God “has not left himself without testimony” (Acts 14:17) even among those who don’t yet know Him by name.

The skeptics are right to demand rigorous investigation and evidence. But the evidence, when examined fairly and completely, points toward the reality of these experiences. The veridical perceptions, the transformative aftereffects, the consistency across cultures, the experiences of young children, the visual experiences of the blind—all converge to suggest that NDEs are genuine glimpses beyond the veil of death.

As we’ve seen throughout this chapter, the shared elements of the NDE form a remarkably consistent narrative. People from all walks of life report leaving their bodies, encountering deceased loved ones, experiencing divine light and unconditional love, reviewing their lives from a perspective of perfect understanding, and returning with a transformed understanding of what matters most in life.

These elements don’t always occur in the same order, and not everyone experiences all of them. As Dr. Moody noted in his original research: “I have found no one person who reports every single component of the composite experience. Very many have reported most of them (that is, eight or more of the fifteen or so) and a few have reported up to twelve” (Moody, Life After Life, Composite Experience). Yet the consistency of the pattern across thousands of cases provides compelling evidence that NDEs represent genuine experiences rather than random hallucinations.

The implications are profound. If consciousness can exist independent of the brain, if love truly is the fundamental force of existence, if our lives have eternal significance, then how we live matters immensely. The message from NDErs is consistent: focus on love, kindness, service to others, and spiritual growth. Material success, social status, and earthly achievements pale in comparison to how we treat others and how we grow in love.

This chapter has examined the common elements that make up the shared journey of the near-death experience. From the initial peace through the encounter with divine light, from the life review to the return with purpose, each element contributes to a coherent narrative that spans cultures and centuries. While mysteries remain and not all questions are answered, the evidence strongly suggests that NDEs offer genuine glimpses into the greater reality that awaits us beyond death.

For those who have had these experiences, they are life-changing revelations that forever alter their understanding of existence. For the rest of us, they offer hope, challenge our assumptions about consciousness and death, and invite us to consider that we may be more than material beings in a material universe. The shared journey of the NDE suggests that we are spiritual beings on a human journey, not human beings hoping for a spiritual experience.

As research continues and more cases are documented and studied, our understanding of these experiences will undoubtedly deepen. But already the evidence is substantial and compelling. The common elements of NDEs, consistent across thousands of cases worldwide, testify to realities beyond our physical senses—realities of consciousness, love, and continued existence that religions have pointed to for millennia.

In the end, the shared journey of the NDE is a journey toward truth—truth about who we are, why we’re here, and what awaits us beyond the threshold of death. It’s a journey that challenges materialism, confirms spiritual realities, and above all, calls us to lives of greater love, compassion, and service. Whether we’ve had an NDE ourselves or simply study the experiences of others, the message is clear: Love is what matters most, consciousness transcends the physical, and death is not the end but a transition to greater life.

The journey continues, both for research into these remarkable experiences and for each of us as we navigate our own paths through life toward whatever lies beyond. The testimony of thousands who have glimpsed the other side offers hope, challenges us to live with greater purpose and love, and suggests that the greatest adventure of all awaits us when we take that final step through the doorway we call death.

May we live with the wisdom they’ve brought back: that every moment matters, every kindness counts, and every soul is precious beyond measure. For in the end, as countless NDErs have discovered, we are all on a shared journey toward the Light—a Light that is not merely illumination but Love itself, waiting to welcome us home.

Bibliography

Atwater, P.M.H. The Big Book of Near-Death Experiences: The Ultimate Guide to the NDE and Its Aftereffects. Charlottesville, VA: Hampton Roads Publishing, 2021.

Burke, John. Imagine Heaven: Near-Death Experiences, God’s Promises, and the Exhilarating Future That Awaits You. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 2015.

Carter, Chris. Science and the Near-Death Experience: How Consciousness Survives Death. Rochester, VT: Inner Traditions, 2010.

Catholic Church. Catechism of the Catholic Church. 2nd ed. Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, 2019.

Greyson, Bruce. After: A Doctor Explores What Near-Death Experiences Reveal about Life and Beyond. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 2021.

Hagan, John C., ed. The Science of Near-Death Experiences. Columbia, MO: University of Missouri Press, 2017.

Long, Jeffrey, and Paul Perry. God and the Afterlife: The Groundbreaking New Evidence for God and Near-Death Experience. New York: HarperOne, 2017.

Miller, J. Steve. Near-Death Experiences as Evidence for the Existence of God and Heaven: A Brief Introduction in Plain Language. Acworth, GA: Wisdom Creek Press, 2012.

Moody, Raymond. Life After Life: The Bestselling Original Investigation That Revealed Near-Death Experiences. 40th Anniversary Edition. New York: HarperOne, 2015.

Ring, Kenneth. Mindsight: Near-Death and Out-of-Body Experiences in the Blind. 2nd ed. Bloomington, IN: iUniverse, 2008.

Rommer, Barbara. Blessing in Disguise: Another Side of the Near Death Experience. St. Paul, MN: Llewellyn Publications, 2000.

Sabom, Michael. Light & Death: One Doctor’s Fascinating Account of Near-Death Experiences. Grand Rapids, MI: Zondervan, 1998.

Sartori, Penny. The Near-Death Experiences of Hospitalized Intensive Care Patients: A Five-Year Clinical Study. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellen Press, 2008.

Van Lommel, Pim. Consciousness Beyond Life: The Science of the Near-Death Experience. New York: HarperOne, 2010.

A Catholic Understanding of the Near Death Experience: Revised Edition. Anonymous theological text from project files.

Is Christianity Compatible With Deathbed and Near-Death Experiences? The Surprising Presence of Jesus, Scarcity of Anti-Christian Elements, And Compatibility with Historic Christian Teachings. Anonymous theological text from project files.

© 2025, LearnTheology.com. All rights reserved.